The question is not which costs less this month
Rent is usually cheaper than owning on the first of the month, and that is the weakest possible comparison. Buying converts part of each payment into equity and exposes you to a leveraged asset; renting keeps you flexible and lets the down payment stay invested. The honest comparison is net worth at the end of the years you actually plan to stay, and the calculator above builds that comparison year by year.
With a $420,000 home, 20% down, a 7.28% mortgage, and $2,600 rent growing 3% a year, the buyer ends ahead from year 8 onward, and the renter ends ahead before that. The first year of ownership costs about $3,175 a month all in, against $2,600 of rent. That gap is real, and it has to be paid for out of the appreciation and the equity that builds up later.
What ownership actually costs
Five costs sit on top of the mortgage payment, and four of them never become equity. Property tax at 1.05% of value runs about $4,410 a year and usually rises with assessments. Homeowners insurance is about $1,900 a year in this example, and it rises with construction costs. Maintenance and repairs at 1% of value is the line most first-time buyers underestimate; a roof, a furnace, and a water heater can arrive in the same eighteen months. HOA dues are a permanent monthly cost in many condos and planned communities. Only principal reduces the loan.
Closing costs bracket the whole holding period. Buying costs, including lender fees, title, appraisal, and recording, typically run 2% to 5% of the price; this model uses 3%. Selling costs, mostly agent commissions plus transfer taxes and title, typically run 5% to 8%; this model uses 6%. Together they mean a home bought and sold within two years usually loses money even if prices rise modestly, which is why the stay horizon dominates the decision.
The opportunity cost of the down payment
The cash that goes into the down payment and buying costs does not disappear; it changes form. In the rent column, that same $96,600 stays invested at 6.5% and compounds for the whole horizon. In the buy column it becomes home equity, which grows only as fast as the home appreciates and cannot be spent without selling or borrowing. This model credits the renter with the invested down payment and with any month where rent is cheaper than ownership, and it credits the buyer with any month where ownership is cheaper than rent.
That symmetry is what makes the comparison fair. A rent-versus-buy calculation that ignores the investment return on the down payment will almost always conclude that buying wins, because it gives the renter no assets at all. A calculation that ignores appreciation will almost always conclude that renting wins. Both are wrong in the same way: they leave out one side of the balance sheet.
Breakeven is a horizon question, not a price question
The breakeven year is the first year when the buyer's net worth, after selling costs and the remaining loan, exceeds the renter's invested savings. It is driven far more by how long you stay than by the purchase price. At the defaults, the answer by holding period looks like this:
| Years you stay | Buyer net worth | Renter net worth | Difference | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 yr | $112,170 | $137,617 | −$25,447 | Rent |
| 5 yr | $151,688 | $166,346 | −$14,658 | Rent |
| 7 yr | $194,730 | $196,189 | −$1,458 | Rent |
| 10 yr | $266,704 | $243,035 | +$23,669 | Buy |
| 15 yr | $416,985 | $326,520 | +$90,464 | Buy |
| 20 yr | $630,644 | $416,221 | +$214,423 | Buy |
The early years belong to the renter because buying and selling costs have to be earned back first. Around the middle of the first decade the equity build and the fixed housing cost overtake the renter's portfolio, and after that the margin widens with every year of appreciation. If your honest answer to "how long will I stay" is three years, the arithmetic above is telling you that renting is not a compromise; it is the better financial choice.
The assumption that swings the answer most
Appreciation is the most sensitive input in the model, and the least knowable. The table below holds everything else at the defaults and changes only the annual rate of home price growth over a ten-year stay:
| Appreciation / yr | Breakeven | Buyer − renter after 10 yr |
|---|---|---|
| 1% | none by 10 yr | −$82,262 |
| 2% | none by 10 yr | −$43,386 |
| 3% | 10 yr | +$154 |
| 4% | 6 yr | +$48,282 |
| 5% | 4 yr | +$100,982 |
Two points follow. First, a flat or falling market can push breakeven past the point where most people actually sell: at 1% or 2% appreciation, owning never catches up inside a decade at these inputs, which argues for buying a home you would be content to keep. Second, the result is not fragile in one direction: at 4% appreciation the buyer pulls ahead by year 6 and at 5% by year 4, which is why markets with tight supply produce so many confident anecdotes. Use a rate you can defend for your own metro area rather than the national average, and test a pessimistic one as well.
What this model leaves out
The model deliberately ignores the mortgage interest and property tax deductions, because since the 2018 standard deduction increase most households take the standard deduction and receive no benefit from either. If you itemize, your effective ownership cost is lower than shown, and the tool will understate the case for buying. It also ignores renters insurance, utilities that differ between the two options, commuting changes, and the value of being able to renovate. It charges maintenance at a flat percentage, which smooths out the lumpy reality of repairs. And it assumes the renter actually invests the difference; a household that spends the monthly savings instead will end the decade with nothing, and then buying wins by default rather than by arithmetic.
Finally, the model assumes you sell at the horizon and pay selling costs. If you never sell, the home's value is not spendable, and the comparison becomes about cash flow, stability, and what you want to leave behind rather than net worth.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 20% down payment always better?
It avoids PMI and lowers the payment, but it also locks up cash. If putting 20% down leaves no emergency fund, a smaller down payment with PMI can be the safer choice. Run the mortgage tool with both down payments and compare the PMI cost against the value of keeping the cash liquid.
Should I include my current rent or the rent I would pay next year?
Use the rent you would actually pay for a comparable home now, not your below-market current lease. If your lease is unusually cheap, the calculator will correctly show renting ahead for longer, because that cheap rent is a real advantage you would be giving up.
What rate of return should I use for the renter's investments?
A diversified portfolio has historically returned around 6% to 7% after inflation over long periods, but with large swings. A conservative 6.5% nominal is a reasonable central case. Test 4% and 8% to see how much the verdict depends on it; if the answer flips, the decision is closer than it looks.
Does this calculator work outside the United States?
The mechanics are general, but the defaults are US: property tax rates, closing cost ranges, PMI, and the treatment of mortgage interest. Change those inputs to local figures before relying on the result.